Founding Partner
You settled your personal injury case, and instead of relief, a letter arrived from your health insurance company demanding repayment for every medical bill they covered. This is not a mistake or a billing error. Most health insurance policies in Maryland include a subrogation clause that gives the insurer the right to recover what they paid from your settlement. The amount they claim can be substantial, sometimes eating into thousands of dollars you expected to keep. A Maryland personal injury attorney can negotiate these claims down and help you hold onto more of your recovery.
Why Does My Insurance Company Want Part of My Settlement?
When your health insurance pays for medical treatment related to an accident, the insurer does not simply absorb those costs. Most policies include a subrogation clause, a provision that gives the company the legal right to seek reimbursement from any settlement or verdict you receive from the at-fault party. This means the insurer effectively steps into your shoes to recover what they spent on your care.
The principle behind subrogation is that you should not collect compensation for the same medical expenses twice. Insurance companies actively track accident-related claims and will typically send a demand letter after your case resolves, listing every expense they covered, from emergency room visits and surgeries to physical therapy and prescription medications. The total can add up quickly, especially in cases involving serious injuries or extended treatment. If you do not recover any money through a settlement or verdict, however, you owe your insurer nothing that you would not ordinarily owe under your policy terms.
Many people first learn about this obligation only after settling an auto accident claim or other personal injury case. Before you receive your share of the settlement, your attorney must account for all outstanding liens, including the insurance company’s subrogation claim, and resolve them from the settlement proceeds.
How Maryland Law Can Reduce What You Owe
Maryland provides important protections that can help you protect your personal injury settlement. Your insurer has no legal obligation to inform you that you might have one or more arguments against subrogation claims. Without an attorney or knowledge of the law, you could end up paying the full demand without ever learning that you were entitled to a substantial reduction.
Statutory Reduction of Subrogation Claim for Attorney Fees
Under Courts and Judicial Proceedings Section 11-112, the amount your health insurer can recover is reduced in proportion to the attorney fees you incurred. The statute calculates this by taking the ratio of attorney fees to your total recovery (capped at one-third), then multiplying that fraction by the insurer’s subrogation claim. That means the maximum reduction can reach one-third of the total subrogation claim.
Important limitation: The statutory reduction does not apply if the health insurer hires its own attorney and files to intervene in your case. In that scenario, the insurer can pursue full reimbursement without contributing to your legal fees.
The “Made Whole Doctrine”
Maryland courts have not clearly adopted the made whole doctrine. Maryland’s only appellate decision on the Made Whole Doctrine, Stancil v. Erie Ins. Co., rejected the doctrine in a homeowner’s insurance subrogation case, but distinguished health‑care cases could be treated differently. An experienced attorney can raise equitable arguments based on this doctrine, as its application to health insurance subrogation specifically remains an open question in Maryland courts.
Auto Insurance — MedPay and PIP
Unlike health insurance subrogation, Maryland law specifically prohibits auto insurers from seeking reimbursement of Medical Payments (MedPay) or Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits paid in a motor vehicle accident case. Under Maryland Insurance Article §§19-109 and 19-507(d), these benefits are yours to keep even if you recover a settlement from the at-fault driver.
Maryland’s statutory ban on MedPay subrogation applies only to motor‑vehicle policies. Therefore, medical‑payments coverage attached to other types of policies (for example, premises liability) may still be subject to subrogation if the policy allows it and no other law prohibits it.
What Types of Liens Can Affect Your Settlement?
Health insurance subrogation is the most common claim against a personal injury settlement, but it is not the only one. Several types of liens can reduce the amount you ultimately take home, and each operates under different rules. Knowing what you are dealing with is the first step toward protecting your recovery.
- Health insurance liens. Your private health insurer seeks reimbursement for accident-related treatment they covered. Maryland’s Section 11-112 attorney fee reduction applies to most of these claims, though the insurer will not volunteer this information.
- Medicare and Medicaid liens. If a federal program covered any of your treatment, the government has a right to recover those payments before settlement funds can be distributed. These federal claims operate on their own timeline and must be resolved before you receive any money.
- ERISA plan liens. If your health coverage comes through a self-insured employer plan governed by federal ERISA law, the plan may be entitled to full reimbursement without the state-law reductions that apply to other policies. These liens are often the most aggressive and the hardest to negotiate.
Understanding which liens apply matters because the available protections vary significantly. A lien from a private Maryland health insurer carries different negotiation leverage than one from a self-insured employer plan or a federal program. Your attorney can identify every outstanding lien, determine which reductions apply, and negotiate each one to help you keep as much of your settlement as possible.
Can Your Insurer Claim Your Entire Settlement?
While subrogation claims can be substantial, insurers face limits on what they can recover. Your health insurance company can only seek reimbursement for expenses directly related to the accident, not for unrelated treatment or costs covered under your policy for other conditions. The amount they claim should reflect only the bills they paid for care directly connected to the injuries in your case.
In Maryland, your attorney can argue that the insurer should bear a share of the cost of obtaining the recovery. Because the insurance company did not hire counsel or fund the litigation, it benefits from your attorney’s work, and the Section 11-112 fee reduction reflects this principle. When the at-fault party carries low insurance limits or liability is disputed, these factors give your attorney additional leverage to negotiate the subrogation amount further down.
Acting before you pay anything is critical. Once you send a check to your insurer, recovering any overpayment becomes far more difficult. An attorney at McGowan & Cecil, LLC can review every lien before settlement funds are distributed, ensuring you do not pay more than what is legally required.
A Maryland Personal Injury Attorney Can Help Protect Your Settlement
If an insurance company is claiming part of your personal injury settlement, you do not have to accept their full demand. The attorneys at McGowan & Cecil, LLC have over 120 years of combined experience handling injury cases across Maryland, including negotiating insurance liens to protect clients’ recoveries. Schedule a free consultation today to learn how we can help you keep more of the compensation you deserve.